Carmines Pie House

Located in the heart of Jacksonville at 2677 Forbes St, Carmines Pie House is a must-visit for lovers of authentic Italian and specialty pizza fare. This pizza restaurant and takeaway spot brings a rich taste of Chicago and New York right to your plate, boasting an array of handcrafted pies and classic Italian dishes that deliver both satisfying comfort and gourmet flair.

Their menu is a treasure trove for pizza enthusiasts, featuring signature items like the deeply indulgent Chicago Stuffed Pizza Pie and the crispy, flavor-packed New York Thin Cheese pizza. For those seeking bold, savory delights, the Chicago Baked Calzone and the Traditional Little Italy N.Y.C. Stromboli are standouts, bursting with layers of sausage, mozzarella, and fresh vegetables, all bathed in a fragrant garlic butter finish. Side dishes like Fried Pickles and Zucchini Fries offer crispy, golden textures with a zesty twist, and their Jumbo Rooster Wings bring the perfect balance of spice and smokiness.

Dessert lovers won’t want to miss the decadent Chocolate Cannoli or the luscious, creamy Tiramisu, each bite melting with rich, authentic Italian flavors that make every meal unforgettable. Meanwhile, the Lobster Mac & Cheese offers a luxurious option that combines creamy comfort with a touch of indulgence.

The dining atmosphere at Carmines Pie House is warmly inviting and genuinely friendly—a sentiment echoed by patrons who repeatedly praise the attentive, knowledgeable staff and the welcoming vibe. From large family gatherings to casual lunch dates, the space feels both lively and comfortable, setting the perfect backdrop for sharing hearty meals and creating lasting memories.

Customers routinely highlight the exceptional hospitality, with one visitor describing the owner Carmine’s personal greetings as setting the tone for a genuinely memorable experience. The server Richard frequently receives accolades for his attentiveness and friendly demeanor, enhancing the overall dining experience with his deep menu knowledge and personalized care.

Beyond great food and service, Carmines Pie House also offers a thoughtfully curated beer selection, including Rolling Rock, Heineken, and Modelo, which perfectly complement the robust flavors of their pizzas and appetizers.

Whether you’re craving a rich deep dish pizza that will satisfy the soul, a crisp, thin New York-style slice, or an expertly rolled calzone packed with fresh toppings, Carmines Pie House is the destination to delight your palate. This local gem not only delivers generous portions and excellent value but also creates an atmosphere where every guest feels like part of the family.

For truly authentic Italian pizza with a welcoming ambiance in Jacksonville, Carmines Pie House is a culinary escape you’ll want to return to again and again.